Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Gabriel Levine's avatar

A small note on the Graduate Research Fellowship Program numbers: for the 2025 application cycle, for which the exceptional 2,599 awards were made early in 2026, NSF narrowed the eligibility criteria so that 2nd-year graduate students could no longer apply. It is now limited to undergraduate seniors and 1st-year graduate students. I do not know why they increased the number of awards, since the size of the applicant pool should have been roughly similar in size. Then-current 2nd-years who had intended to apply got the shaft, meaning that there was no glut of applications from them.

IMO, this is a good change, as it selects for raw promise in incoming graduate students, before they can be molded too heavily by the group they join or, in some cases, be assigned a project to shape an application around by their advisor.

Siebe's avatar

Thanks for this update. Remarkably promising!

This may not be the best place to ask, but I'm curious about the tension between the rigidity of pre-registration/registered reports on the hand hand versus long duration grants & researcher freedom in focused Research organizations in the other hand.

Registered reports really help cutting down on the pressure or ability to publish (false) positive results. Giving scientists less structure than usual seems directly in conflict with this, and requires solid culture and strong hiring. For each Bell Labs there may be multiple money pits that produce little to no value. Can both of these exist in the same ecosystem?

Feel free to point me to reading rather than answering this question directly.

Ready for more?